Professor Nyhan on Bright Line Watch polling
Professor Brendan Nyhan, a member of the Steering Committee of the Program in Quantitative Social Science (QSS) and the James O. Freedman Presidential Professor of Government at Dartmouth College, was recently mentioned in a New York Times article titled, "America Is Playing With Fire." The article examines Donald Trump's second-term agenda, focusing on his plan to politicize federal agencies, prioritize prosecuting domestic enemies, and weaken democratic norms through initiatives like Schedule F. It highlights his rhetoric against NATO commitments, praise for authoritarian leaders, and divisive policies appealing to the MAGA base, raising concerns about potential threats to democracy and civil liberties.
Professor Nyhan is one of the founders of Bright Line Watch, a project that regularly polls political scientists and the larger public to gauge "potential danger to American democratic norms and institutions." From September 25 to October 8, Bright Line Watch surveyed 549 political science experts in the US and 2,750 Americans. Among the findings of its recent poll are that political scientists rated the Supreme Court's July 1 ruling in Trump v. United States, which established broad presidential immunity from criminal prosecution, as the most significant threat to democracy among the events listed. "In total," Bright Line Watch reported, "86 percent of experts rated [the Trump v. United States decision] as a threat to democracy, including 75 percent who viewed it as either a serious or extraordinary threat."
In Winter 2025, Professor Nyhan will be teaching GOVT 10: Quantitative Political Analysis and GOVT 35: The Presidency.